The tragedy of dying young is that you don’t get to outlive your relevance. The tragedy of old age is that you do. A friend of mine posted on Facebook that he was feeling down because he didn’t receive any votes in this year’s Downbeat Critics Poll, so he went out and bought a pair of fabulous sneakers. Being a fantastic saxophonist who is well known to musicians, he got more than a few loving responses.
My response was that in my 50-year professional career, I got exactly one vote in that same poll, 45 years ago when I was first starting out. In fact, that is the only poll of any kind that I have ever appeared in. And yet, I’ve had quite a fulfilling career. I went on to mention that just that afternoon I rehearsed some of my new charts for my band and got to experience music on the highest level for three solid hours. I wouldn’t trade that for a million dollars or the adoration of myriads of fans.
The point of all this is that artists do what we do for the love of the art and for personal growth and expression. No one understands our art as well as we understand it. No one knows me as well as I know myself. Yes, others can have some insights, but no one can completely know another person’s soul.
Now that I am a senior citizen, the number of gigs I’m called for has dwindled. I’m not offered teaching positions. This seems wrong to me since I’ve learned so much over the years and am a much better musician, composer, arranger and communicator than I was when I was a young man and in demand. The painful truth is that there are very few young people who think that anyone much older than they are can understand their world and help them.
It’s true that my taste in music, clothes, all the other arts, and people in general may be different from kids 40 or 50 years my junior, but we have a lot more in common that they realize. Sure, I haven’t kept up with pop culture. I don’t watch reality shows (other than the Trump presidency), nor do I know any pop music of the past 40 years. I may not be able to afford the best restaurants on a regular basis, but I have eaten in many of them, and I have developed my palate since my picky eater childhood. I read new books, see new movies and watch TV series that interest me.
My respect for the classics, be it Louis Armstrong, Mozart, van Gogh, et al. has not stopped me from following their lead to Ellington, Miles Davis, Stravinsky and Jackson Pollock. With that same zeal for innovation I have developed my own music and have championed other contemporary artists who have built on the past and shown us the future. Just because I love the past doesn’t preclude me embracing innovation. Where I differ from most critics is that I demand more of a connection to our cultural heritage than “It’s new, man!”
I was thinking about Philip Roth the other day. He wrote Portnoy’s Complaint when he was 36. It was an instant bestseller, as well it should have been. He wrote book after incredible book for the next 50 years, and never received that level of recognition again. Did he peak at that tender age, or was he just not in sync with the zeitgeist? Or does the public, which is a generation or two or three younger just think that he’s irrelevant to their modern lives? What could some old codger talking about the Newark of the 1940s have to do with America now? After all, the Jews left Newark after the riots of the ’60s and condemned the city to urban blight and poor people. Are there any lessons to be learned here? Is there anything to be learned from studying Duke Ellington’s scores? God, I hope so, or I’ve wasted a whole lotta my time over the past 50 years.
When I was going through a fallow patch financially about 20 years ago, I expressed my concern about my future to my mother, who by that time was in her 70s. She advised me that she had lived long enough to see that life is cyclical. I might be down now, but I’ll be up again, and then down again, and so on. Time has proved her right. I’m an optimist. I get pretty dark sometimes, but I have faith that things will even out in the long run.
Will I ever get the recognition I got in my youth? Probably not. Does that matter to me? Probably not. I became a musician so that I could spend my life sharing my music with others and constantly working on my craft, so that I could get as close to perfection as possible. I shoot for the moon. I haven’t hit it yet, but I keep getting closer.
The musicians in my band have been with me for long enough to appreciate what I’m up to, and I appreciate that they stick with me and enjoy playing my music. They breathe life into the little black dots on the page. They express who they are within the structures that I set up. This excites me and keeps me forever young. It’s a shame that we don’t have more opportunity to reach a wide audience like we once did, but I remain hopeful. The blues teaches us that “the sun’s gonna shine on my backdoor someday.” In the meantime I’m enjoying every day and every note that goes through my head.
Just saw an excellent interview/documentary on Phillip Roth. No one had heard of him before PORTNOY. And then, the book was a sensation.
Saying he never achieved that “level of recognition”, makes me think of the sensation Frank Sinatra caused, at the Paramount, with his screaming bobbysoxers. He also, never got that level of recognition. But, he certainly didn’t peak! I loved Roth, and I’m not in his generation. God forbid, these people tried to stay “in sync” with fashion. Sinatra hated rock & roll, and Roth stayed with what was most familiar to him. If your career lasts, as there’s did, for their lifetime and beyond, I’d stay they’ve peaked, and peaked, and peaked!
David, thank you not only for sharing your thoughts and perspective today, but for all you have done, for all you do, and, God willing/inshallah, all you will do. You are a treasure!
BRAVO, Dave! Perfectly parsed! Thanks! XO – M
David Berger…..you’re my musical and human rock in the professional world! I like being a long distance runner and never felt it lonely. I actually have run a half marathon and a biathlon. There is a great pleasure and sense of balance in hitting ones own mark. Each one of us has a special calling and that, in a sense, is lonely work sometimes. For me, it’s helped me to stand back and observe the status quo of things and I can tell you a great many things are backwards…..and on purpose I might add. It’s euphoric delivering your gift, but then, so many of us may be giving our gifts at the same time and it’s hard to choose…..Your words ring true and are a refuge from the ever changing scenes accomodating the current generations! Ever Up and Onward…..B. Strayhorn
Your as-always-eloquent writing made me think of something. I’ve known lots of peeps over the years that have the finest taste in everything: books, art, films, etc., except when it comes to music. For some reason, they prefer listening to what they consider to be “underground” god-awful stuff rather than classical, Jazz or even good “pop music” that has stood the test of time. I just don’t get it.